Rosemary Gimlet

Rosemary Gimlet Cocktail Recipe
Some say, “You eat with your eyes.” I don’t know about you, but until my eyes start sporting incisors, I’ll continue to use my mouth. Especially when drinking cocktails.

I was recently at a bar that specialized in herbal concoctions and ordered a Rosemary Gimlet. I’ve been focusing a little more on gin these days, favoring an ice-cold martini over my usual whiskey or rye-based drinks. Partially because I was in the states and people kept making Manhattans and other cocktails way too sweet. One said-to-be reputable bar served me a Manhattan with extra maraschino cherry juice in the glass. If I wasn’t so respectful of bartenders, I would have lept over the bar and made her stop. What’s up with that?

I tend to like my cocktails on the tangy or on the rugged side, rather than too fruity or sweet. Herbs, I can go either way on. Rosemary in particular, is one of those herbs that if you use a little too much of it, the taste can be medicinal. But when I saw it paired with gin and lime juice on a bar menu in New York, I figured it would be a nice combination for a winter cocktail. And after my first sip, I was convinced that it was.

Rosemary Gimlet Cocktail Recipe

The only issue I had with the one that I’d ordered was that it was served in a thick glass, shaped like a deep cone tapering downward, resting on a base with no stem. It was more appropriate to what you might find at an airport lounge rather than an upscale cocktail bar, where drinks were going for $14 a pop, plus tax and tip. While chatting with the barman, I did mention that the cocktail was tasty, but the glass could have used an updating. He replied that that’s what they had on hand, which seemed a shame.

We may not be able to eat with our eyes (and if you can, please share a video…or, er, maybe not…), but how a cocktail tastes can depend on the glass. At least to me. Just like we all have our own favorite coffee cup, a cocktail glass provides a visceral experience that can’t always be explained. Wine pros will talk about how the shape of the glass focuses certain flavors of the wine to specific parts of your tongue that will enhance the experience, which is probably true. So is it too hard to want a cocktail in a proper glass? (And unless you’re from the south, hold the jam jars!)

Rosemary Gimlet Cocktail RecipeA friend of mine told me about going to a swanky hotel in Manhattan for a martini, and her favorite part was the glass. She described it as having a curved shape, like a typical martini glass, but at the very top, right before the rim, the glass curved in just a little bit, which she reiterated with the tips of her index fingers cocking inwards. From that tiny gesture, I could tell exactly how that cold martini tasted as it slipped through her lips.

Rosemary Gimlet Cocktail Recipe

Ditto with a gimlet. Icy gin needs to be served in a stemmed glass, as your hands will warm the drink. When I’m roaming through thrift stores and flea markets, I pick up cocktail glasses when I see ones that interest me. For some reason, cocktail glasses tend to get broken more often than other glasses, which may be why some people just give up and use jam jars. (Spoiler: Those French “working glasses” that they sell for drinks in America, no one uses for drinks in France.) But being a thrifty guy, I buy cocktail glasses when they’re $1 a pop, if I can, and treat myself to a proper glass. Like the ones here that I bought at a Goodwill shop.

Rosemary Gimlet Cocktail Recipe

The name “Gimlet” sounds like something that might be sipped in a more genteel era, when the proper glass was de rigeur. Modern tastes now swap out fresh lime juice for the sweetened bottled stuff. And unless I didn’t get the memo, you can use any kind of gin that you like. I picked up this bottle of dry rye gin, made by St. George Spirits, perhaps hoping to capture some of the former glory of the rye whiskey-based Manhattans that I knew and loved so well.

I knew the Jörg Rupf, the German founder of the company, back when he was tinkering away with his oak barrels and distiller, in a hangar, making eau-de-vies and other spirits that few in America had ever heard of. (He once made a holly berry eau-de-vie that was kind of wacky, for Christmas. He also laughed about how little business he did: At the time, his biggest restaurant account went through 1/2 bottle of liquor every two months.) Now the company has shifted hands, right about the time cocktails reemerged in America, and seems to be going gangbusters.

Although Jörg has retired, the new team is doing some very interesting things, like this gin. I found the rye a bit too “present” for a martini, but was spot-on in this gimlet. But feel free to use a favorite gin, because you should always judge a liquor by the flavor, not by the bottle. Unless, of course, you drink with your eyes.

Rosemary Gimlet Cocktail Recipe

 

Rosemary Gimlet
Print Recipe
Makes one cocktail
Rosemary adds a lovely resiny flavor to this cocktail, with pairs nicely with the tart lime and juniper-rich gin. However it is a flavor that can quickly overwhelm. I found the amount in the syrup that I used to be just right. But if you’re a bit apprehensive, you can dial it back to 1 1/2 tablespoons (about 3g). The rosemary syrup will make enough for about eight or so cocktails. It can be kept in the refrigerator for several weeks. It’s also nice drizzled over fresh orange slices for dessert. This is a great winter cocktail and if you don’t want to use the rosemary, you can make a sugar syrup without it and use that. (Or you can get creative and infuse something else in the syrup.) The recipe can be scaled up to whatever will fit comfortably in a cocktail shaker. Most cocktail shakers can handle two drinks at the same time.
Rosemary Syrup
1/2 cup (125ml) water
1/2 cup (100g) sugar
2 tablespoons (4g) coarsely chopped fresh rosemary leaves
Rosemary Gimlet
2 ounces gin
3/4 ounce fresh lime juice
3/4 ounce rosemary syrup
1. To make the rosemary syrup, heat the water, sugar and chopped rosemary leaves in a small saucepan, stirring occasionally, until the mixture is hot and sugar is dissolved. Remove from heat and let cool completely. Once cool, strain the rosemary syrup into a jar, and refrigerate until ready to use.
2. To make the rosemary gimlet, chill a stemmed cocktail glass in the freezer.
3. Measure the gin, lime juice and rosemary syrup into a cocktail shaker. Fill the shaker halfway with ice, preferably slightly crushed, cover, and shake the cocktail mixture about thirty seconds. Pour into a chilled cocktail glass. Garnish with a sprig of rosemary or a slice of fresh lime.

Never miss a post!

51 comments

  • Craig
    November 30, 2015 1:45pm

    The Rosemary Gimlet… just brilliant!
    Thanks.

  • November 30, 2015 3:18pm

    And, David, I’m glad to see a properly shaken gimlet!

  • Paula
    November 30, 2015 4:50pm

    Yes, the correct cocktail glass. I made a gin martini last night for the first time in ages and could not find my favorite martini glass! I ended up using the plastic martini glass I bought for cocktails by the pool. Not good, but it did cool down enough after about 15 minutes in the freezer. I’m ordering my favorite glass, Viv from Crate and Barrel, today.

  • November 30, 2015 5:17pm

    This is just what I need for the holidays. A fresh spin on gin. I looove rosemary. Running to make this now… (er in a few hours… when it’s five o’clock somewhere).

  • November 30, 2015 5:41pm

    Hey David! Seeing as you’re a fan of gin I wonder if you like sloe gin? Don’t know if it’s popular in your neck of the woods but in UK everyone’s out there picking the wild sloe berries come fall (add gin and sugar and leave for several months before decanting) to make a wonderful sloe gin (think sloe gin fizz) Tastes wonderful!

    • Sharon
      November 30, 2015 8:07pm

      After a serious introduction in my college years, I have forever since foregone sloe gin. F O R E V E R.

      • Be
        December 1, 2015 12:20am

        Me, too! And I had my sloe gin experience 45 years ago. Still makes me shudder.

  • carla west
    November 30, 2015 5:41pm

    We lived in the East Bay while St George was growing up and enjoyed the fun tours…oh, and the tastings. BTW, we heard Rupf also put an entire christmas tree in the distiller. Next time you’re in SF, find some spirits by a new guy in Santa Cruz, Sean Venus. He’s got a great palate….his agave reposada is world-class, as are the gins. Beautiful bottles too.

    • November 30, 2015 6:36pm
      David Lebovitz

      Yes Jörg was one of those people who was really on the cusp of things changing in the Bay Area. I went to his distillery a few times. Once he had found a barrel of apple brandy that he had forgotten about in a corner for ten years, which he laughed about. (Of course, it was amazing.) And another time he called me because he had some excess fruit that he didn’t know what to do with. When I arrived, there were hundreds (and hundreds) of ten gallon buckets of pear, raspberry, and other fruit pulps, that he had used for the distillations and he didn’t know what to do with them all. I would have taken some, but it was a lot. He told me it took 60 pounds of pears to make a bottle of eau-de-vie, so now when I see a bottle for $20-30, it seems like a bargain!

  • November 30, 2015 5:48pm

    Such a lovely, sophisticated drink for the holidays! I love gimlets but have never thought to try one with rosemary – such a good idea!

  • Marie Giacalone
    November 30, 2015 6:09pm

    Definitely going to try this! I love your Thrift Store tip. I am always amazed at the fab glasses I can buy for almost nothing.

  • Patti
    November 30, 2015 6:13pm

    Hi David,
    This cocktail sounds delicious! Is it being served in Paris? We will be there the week of Christmas and I think my daughter-in-law would love it.

    • November 30, 2015 6:40pm
      David Lebovitz

      There are some excellent cocktail bars in Paris but not sure if one is serving this drink. I’ve profiled a few favorite bars in the site, like Le Mary Celeste and Pas de Loup, but you might want to have a look at 52 Martinis as Forest really does a good job scoping out the Paris cocktail scene.

      • Patti
        November 30, 2015 7:50pm

        Thank you so much!

  • November 30, 2015 6:27pm

    I have not tried rosemary in a cocktail before, but this sounds fantastic and so season-appropriate! You are so right about the glass in which a cocktail like this should be served. I am not a cocktail expert, but I do like an appropriate glass for each drink-alcohol or not. It does make a difference.

  • Kathleen
    November 30, 2015 6:34pm

    This slays me. Well worth watching to the end. Thought it somewhat appropriate for your post today! Enjoy!
    https://www.facebook.com/chrisousa/videos/10208490261599424/

  • November 30, 2015 6:35pm

    David – thanks so much. My sister-in-law just gave me a huge bag of key limes from her tree. Perfect timing. Shake. Shake. Shake.

  • November 30, 2015 6:44pm

    Yum! I love herby cocktails. This one’s beauty.

    Totally agree with you about the importance of the glass. Traditional martini glasses, for one, make me a bit anxious. Why is there no lip on the glass?! It is so prone to spillage that despite how awesome martinis may be, I never order them for fear of getting one in that triangular vessel. Getting anxious just thinking about it…

    • December 1, 2015 6:20pm

      YES! same. I don’t have particularly shaky hands, but martini glasses are a disaster for me.

  • Simon
    November 30, 2015 7:30pm

    I read somewhere that the slightly rounded martini glass was based on the shape (and size) of Marie Antoinette’s breast. Since you’re in France, perhaps you can confirm! Love your stories.

  • Jacque Dewolf
    November 30, 2015 7:30pm

    Your recipe for Rosemary Gimlet sounds delicious. Plan on making it soon. We are snowed in at Eagle Crest resort where we now live and there are lots of Juniper trees where I can make my own gin. Lol
    Your blog is my favorite.

  • November 30, 2015 7:31pm

    Oh!!! This reminds of the best martini I ever had (in Fredericksburg VA, no less). Although from their homemade vodka, it was mulled with radish, flavored with a rosemary syrup, served icey cold in a proper stemmed glass with a shivering sliver of radish afloat. Your post here has inspired me to replicate that drink, and of course your Gimlet as well. Also, I too scout for oddball highballs and cocktail glasses at my favorite thrift haunts. This way, breaks are only to one’s glass, not heart, unless of course, the drink was just poured!

  • November 30, 2015 7:35pm

    I almost always prefer my cocktails in a coup glass rather than a martini glass- most martini glasses I see are monsters, and coups tend to be restrained and elegant. I’m definitely not opposed to drinking out of a jam jar, but it has to be the right kind of cocktail- something informal and summery works best. I’ve had very mixed luck with gimlets, from excellent to deeply sad, but this one looks very tasty.

  • November 30, 2015 7:40pm

    Is it really only 10:40 in the morning? Blast!!

  • xt
    November 30, 2015 7:41pm

    Intrigued by the Rye gin. We’ve been experiemnting with rye in all its spiritual forms this past year, but love our gin, so this sounds like a great match.
    Right with you on the jam jars–another unfortunate american trend I wish had never happened!

  • GuyB
    November 30, 2015 8:35pm

    “Wine pros will talk about how the shape of the glass focuses certain flavors of the wine to specific parts of your tongue that will enhance the experience, which is probably true.”

    Wine pros say a lot of things, most of them completely unreproducible and unverifiable.

  • elena
    November 30, 2015 8:48pm

    Fantastic!
    Thank you so much!

  • November 30, 2015 8:53pm
    David Lebovitz

    xt: Because I love rye, and gin, I thought this was an interesting combination. Once I get through the bottle (which shouldn’t be long!), however, I’m going to try the other two gins that St. George makes.

    The jam jar trend, like verrines in France (food served in glasses & jars), was interesting at first. But like many trends, they get worn out. They make sense in the south, where I think that originated. But basta!

    Jacque: There’s actually a Pine bud cone syrup that I’ve always wanted to try. Not sure what parts of the pine tree are edible, but maybe you’ve got some rosemary poking up through the snow? ; )

    simon: That story has been myth-busted, but stories like that do tend to take a life on their own. Thanks – and glad you like the blog!

  • Kari
    November 30, 2015 9:09pm

    The world’s best gin: Helsinki Times

  • Jeanne
    November 30, 2015 10:06pm

    14$ a pop plus tax and tip! How things have changed. That’s why I drink at home. Love gimlets and have a huge Rosemary bush in my garden. Will give your suggestion a try. Keep up the good work.

  • Nikki
    November 30, 2015 10:07pm

    While this looks wonderful..the glass with the sprig of Rosemary. I am with Sharon on the gin or Sloe gin after an experience in college I can not abide the smell of Juniper. So much so it took me years to get rid of a juniper bush by my back door. I love Rosemary and the fragrance is wonderful. I now have to find a way to use the Rosemary syrup I now want to make. Any suggestions? Might have to find a use so I will have something to go with a Rosemary Chocolate Pie that I love making..just to surprise people with the unusual ingredient.

  • Amy
    November 30, 2015 11:09pm

    It’s times like this that I wish I liked gin…

    Rosemary must be the “it” herb, as I’ve seen a lot of drinks with it this season. I made a cocktail (a twist on the Moscow Mule) for Thanksgiving with a cranberry-infused simple syrup, vodka, ginger beer, and lime. The recipe also called for rosemary ice cubes and a short sprig of rosemary on the side of the glass. It was a hit! I think it’ll be back for our Christmas Eve party.

  • Joe Morris
    December 1, 2015 12:02am

    While you’ve got rosemary syrup in the fridge, rosemary Greyhounds also quite nice. Just swap in grapefruit juice for the lime juice.

    I’ve always just tossed in a sprig or three of rosemary when the simple syrup is done dissolving but still hot, pull it out when cool, to avoid the chopping and straining steps.

  • Gavrielle
    December 1, 2015 1:26am

    I was nodding so vigorously through this that my head almost fell off. Oh, and while we’re chucking out jam jars, can we add stemless wine glasses to the pile?

  • Lisa
    December 1, 2015 2:03am

    This is going on the “Christmas Cocktail” menu! Sounds like just the perfect thing to serve as a signature holiday beverage.

    Thanks David!

  • Lulu
    December 1, 2015 9:15am

    So, it sounds like the spruce-infused rye I made would be right up your alley? Worth a try if you find yourself with a spruce tree to plunder.

  • JB
    December 1, 2015 1:57pm

    Hi David,
    One of our local restaurants is featuring a menu based on your recent cookbook, see : http://www.amical.com.
    We’ll be heading over there for dinner, excited about getting a real taste of Paris.

  • Eileen
    December 1, 2015 9:14pm

    Hi, I know this is off-topic, but I since we all LOVE chocolate it’s not *too* far….
    I know Dutch-cocoa is alkalized, and I saw in your cocoa that “most European cocoas are Dutched” but both Nestle and Van Houten (what they have in the supermarket) says 100% cacao…..so I was wondering if they’re natural or not. (I’m in France)

    Thanks!

    • December 2, 2015 12:55pm
      David Lebovitz

      I buy cocoa powder in bulk in Europe so I don’t have a package with the ingredient on it but the Van Houton website lists their cocoa powder as alkalized (Dutched) – not sure about other brands, but you can check their websites. (Valrhona cocoa powder, which I tend to use, is alkalized although it’s not listed as an ingredient.)

  • December 1, 2015 10:18pm

    Yum, David. Yum yum yum. I lean toward rye and bourbon, especially in the winter but I love the label on your bottle of gin. And since I’m very easily swayed by aesthetics, one of these babies is definitely in my near future.

  • Allyn
    December 2, 2015 12:20am

    Oh my goodness, this is my new favorite cocktail!!! I love gin, I love lime, I love gimlets and I love rosemary . . . the combination is just wonderful! Thanks in advance for making this holiday season so much more festive!!

  • December 2, 2015 12:59am

    St. George Spirits is my favorite distillery. We go several times a year to see what new things they come up with!
    Kari

  • Sher
    December 2, 2015 3:48am

    The gimlet was truly refreshing and a nice change from from usual martini….not too sweet, not too tart! I had a second one just to be sure I was right about the first one being absolutely delicious!

  • Julie De Meester
    December 3, 2015 4:14pm

    I happen to have sage syrup on hand which I bought (incidentally) because I loved the old fashioned pharmacist bottle it came in. I wonder if that would work in here too…

    • December 3, 2015 7:30pm
      David Lebovitz

      Sage would be lovely. Like rosemary, a little sage goes a long way. So if it’s very strong, I would cut it with some water or a bit of unflavored simple syrup.

  • LWood
    December 5, 2015 4:05am

    Love the Bruno story. And agree that American cocktails are often too sweet.

  • tara@littlehomekitchen.wordpress
    December 5, 2015 10:21pm

    This sounds just perfect – not too sweet, not too harsh, warmly aromatic and somewhat resin-y, which seems right for the season. David, I think you and I are sympatico with cocktails. (Then again, you had me way back with your barrel of ageing negronis…) Thanks!

  • kathy
    December 7, 2015 12:14am

    This gimlet is seriously delicious. I went a little light on the rosemary the first time around, but my husband and I both agreed it needed the full 2 tablespoons. I am whipping up another batch of syrup right now!

  • Carole
    December 9, 2015 12:33am

    I was impatient to try this tempting recipe so I made changes. Since I definitely don’t care for gin I used vodka and instead of making the rosemary syrup I muddled it with agave syrup in the cocktail shaker. Next time I will make the syrup but I have to say my cocktail is fabulous!
    Thanks!

  • michelle
    December 11, 2015 8:02am

    This. This is Christmas. I think I enjoyed it as much as my cat enjoys drinking water from the Christmas tree stand. I enjoyed it so much I have given gin, limes and rosemary, along with the recipe, as a gift no less than 4 times this season! I have one small addition to suggest… along with the sprig of rosemary garnish, I dropped in 2 cranberries. They hang out like little ornaments and look lovely! Cheers!

  • DavidBWL
    December 14, 2015 6:06am

    We took a chance tonight and made these for a couple of guests we really didn’t know (actually, I had never met them before tonight). Anyway, holy s**t! It just blew everybody’s minds. What a simple and beautiful drink. I just love when something so delicious can come from 3 or 4 ingredients. Thank you!